Dave Mustaine Decides Which Is Better: Metallica’s or Megadeth’s Take on ‘Ride the Lightning’

Jamie Collins
By
Jamie Collins
Jamie serves as our Cultural Historian, focusing on the social impact, career milestones, and cultural significance of the 80s and 90s rock scene. He specializes in...
4 Min Read
Photo Credit: Jason Laveris/FilmMagic - Paras Griffin/Getty Images

Dave Mustaine recently addressed questions about Megadeth’s rendition of “Ride the Lightning” for the band’s upcoming final album. This was reported by Kerrang.

When asked whether the new version should be classified as a cover, Mustaine emphasized his unique position regarding the track. Since he co-wrote the original song, he argued that calling it a cover doesn’t accurately reflect the nature of the recording.

“No. Because I wrote the song too. I think other people will say that, but if you’re asking me, I don’t think it’s a cover song,” Mustaine said.

Mustaine also weighed in on how the Megadeth version compares to Metallica’s original. The response from those familiar with both versions has been consistently positive, according to the musician.

“When it was done, we played it for a couple of people, and a lot of people we know are fans of that band and that song, so they knew what they were listening to, A vs. B, and the consensus has been pretty much the same – that we did a fitting homage. I think we did it at least as good – it’s a little faster,” he explained.

This rendition carries deeper significance than a typical cover. It marks a poignant moment in metal history as Megadeth prepares to conclude their legendary career. The inclusion of “Ride the Lightning” on the band’s final album represents far more than a musical tribute—it’s a reflection on decades of shared history and creative contributions between two of thrash metal’s most influential acts.

Megadeth’s version of “Ride the Lightning” is faster, played in a lower key, and sung differently than the Metallica original, according to Guitar World. This gives it a distinctly Megadeth character while honoring the source material. The track serves as a bridge between Mustaine’s past with Metallica and his legacy with Megadeth. It acknowledges his early creative input on Metallica songs during his time as the band’s original lead guitarist.

Megadeth’s self-titled final album is scheduled for release on January 23, 2026, according to Loudwire. This marks the official end of the band’s active career. The timing makes the inclusion of “Ride the Lightning” particularly meaningful, as it allows Mustaine to revisit a foundational moment in his musical journey during the band’s farewell.

Mustaine frames the track not as competition but as a mark of respect toward Metallica and James Hetfield. He emphasizes their role in shaping metal guitar and the genre’s landscape. Consequence noted that this gesture is especially significant given Mustaine’s complex history with Metallica. He was their original lead guitarist before forming Megadeth, and a long-standing rivalry existed between the bands. By revisiting “Ride the Lightning” in Megadeth’s final album, Mustaine both honors that legacy and symbolically concludes his musical journey.

The comments come as Megadeth prepares to embark on their global farewell tour. This marks a significant moment for the legendary thrash metal band and provides fans with a final opportunity to witness one of metal’s most influential acts perform live.

Share This Article