Mike Portnoy’s Son Makes Surprising Confession About His Father’s Dream Theater Exit

Eliza Vance
By
Eliza Vance
Eliza specializes in the celebrity side of the rock/metal sphere, examining inter-artist relations, social media trends, and fan community engagement. She expertly interprets popular culture through...
5 Min Read
Photo Credit: Max Portnoy/Instagram

Dream Theater drummer Mike Portnoy and his son Max discussed the time Mike left the band, with Max revealing he has no memory of his father’s departure, speaking on Drumeo.

Create your own music artist with RockAgent
You follow artists every day. What about creating your own?
RockAgent lets you build a music artist from scratch and take it all the way to release.
Create Your Artist

The two talked about events from when Max was around 10 or 11 years old. Mike Portnoy had been touring with Avenged Sevenfold when he decided to step away from Dream Theater. Max was asked whether he remembered what that period was like for the family.

Question: “And Max, do you remember like after that tour what that was like? Do you remember your dad leaving the band?”

“No, not at all,” Max Portnoy said. “[laughs] I really I talked to Melody about this like a month or two ago. I’m just like I straight up do not remember at all. And I was like old enough. I was like what 10 years old? 11.”

Mike Portnoy responded with surprise at his son’s lack of memory. “You were 10 or 11. I was on tour with Avenge Sevenfold when I left the Theater. You don’t remember? It’s weird that you could remember tours from when you were like six years old.”

Max acknowledged this oddity. “It’s kind of crazy. I don’t remember at all. I don’t know. I do remember you like playing me like a little piece of heaven and being like, ‘Oh, yeah. I’m playing with these guys’ or something like watching Avenge stuff and I was like, ‘Oh, go cool.’ And but I don’t remember you leaving or anything.”

Mike Portnoy then shared details of what happened during that tour period. “Oh, god. I remember I was with you. Not to get too into it, but yeah. I remember you guys were on tour with me right before I left. Cuz you guys spent about a week on tour with me when I was out with Avenge Sevenfold and we had a separate bus and we had you and Melody and me and Mommy and you and Melody each brought a friend.”

He continued with more specifics about the moment he informed Dream Theater of his situation. “I remember you did a bunch of shows on the East Coast and we had a day off after the New Jersey show. We went to New York City and that’s when I met with Dream Theater in New York City and you guys were with me and I went and had the meeting with those guys to let them know that… I well at that time I just wanted a break. I hadn’t decided to leave the band yet, but I told them what I was feeling and what I was hoping for and looking you know hoping that we would agree to. But in any case, you guys were with me when that happened.”

The conversation took place in an interview format where the two reflected on a significant moment in both their lives and the band’s history.

Portnoy announced his departure from Dream Theater on September 8, 2010, while touring with Avenged Sevenfold. He cited burnout and his desire for a break as reasons for leaving. Only after the rest of the band rejected his proposal to take time away did Portnoy decide to officially quit the group.

The departure sparked tension between Portnoy and vocalist James LaBrie that lasted for years. LaBrie commented that Dream Theater was more balanced without “somebody in the background trying to grab the limelight,” while Portnoy made critical remarks about the band in interviews. The two did not speak again for eleven years until a 2022 show in New York, when tensions finally began to ease.

In October 2023, thirteen years after his departure, Dream Theater announced that Portnoy would return to the band. He played on John Petrucci’s solo album during the pandemic, which opened the door to reconciliation. Dream Theater released their album Parasomnia on February 7, 2025, their first with Portnoy since 2009’s Black Clouds & Silver Linings, and launched their 40th-anniversary North American tour that same month.

Share This Article