Michael Anthony Reveals the Female Singer Who Could Have Changed Van Halen’s History

Eliza Vance
By
Eliza Vance
Eliza specializes in the celebrity side of the rock/metal sphere, examining inter-artist relations, social media trends, and fan community engagement. She expertly interprets popular culture through...
5 Min Read
Photo Credit: Scott Dudelson/Getty Images

Former Van Halen bassist Michael Anthony discussed the search for a new frontman after David Lee Roth’s departure, speaking at a Q&A at the Rock ‘N’ Roll Fantasy Camp. He addressed reports that Eddie Van Halen considered female singers for the role.

Create your own music artist with RockAgent
You follow artists every day. What about creating your own?
RockAgent lets you build a music artist from scratch and take it all the way to release.
Create Your Artist

Anthony was asked about claims that Sammy Hagar was not the band’s first choice to replace Roth when Van Halen parted with the frontman in 1985.

“You’re getting into kind of a gray area there,” Anthony said. “Patty Smyth actually was considered at one point. And this was Eddie. When Dave left, it kind of threw us all in a bit of a tailspin.”

The situation created uncertainty within the band. “[Our record label] Warner Brothers, they wanted us to change the name of the band right away, hoping that one day Dave would come back, and we could resume the Van Halen thing,” Anthony explained. “But it was kind of like the fairy tale was over, the initial success that we had with the band.”

Eddie Van Halen was exploring options at the time. “And Ed, he was kind of freaking out a bit,” Anthony continued. “And there were quite a few people that either jammed with us or Ed had spoken to, so we really didn’t know. We all kind of decided [in the end that] we didn’t need Patty Smyth to come in, having a girl come in singing songs about girls. It wasn’t gonna fit.”

Anthony also mentioned other singers who were considered for the band over the years. “There’s a guy by the name of Mitch Malloy. Anybody remember him?” he said. “I just did a show in Vegas [Sally Steele’s eighth Vegas Rocks! Magazine Music Awards, which took place on September 20, 2026 at The Orleans Showroom at The Orleans Hotel & Casino]…. This girl Sally Steele has an award show in Vegas every year. And they wanted me to come up and jam at the end, and they said, ‘Well, Mitch Malloy’s gonna be there.’ And he had actually met with Ed and Al [Van Halen drummer Alex Van Halen]. He sang on some stuff that Ed had written, but it was kind of a real short-lived deal. He thought that he was gonna be in the band, and then all of a sudden Gary Cherone… It was kind of a weird type of deal.”

The remarks came during Anthony’s appearance at the Rock ‘N’ Roll Fantasy Camp. The band eventually settled on Sammy Hagar as the new lead singer.

Patty Smyth was actually offered the position after Roth’s departure in 1985, but she declined the opportunity. Eddie Van Halen and his wife Valerie Bertinelli were friends with Smyth, and Eddie offered her the job directly. Smyth turned it down because of lifestyle and location concerns, citing that the band were heavy drinkers while she did not drink, and that she did not see herself living in Los Angeles, being from New York.

The band brought in Sammy Hagar to replace Roth in 1985. Van Halen released their first album with Hagar, 5150, on March 24, 1986, and the partnership proved successful with four studio albums recorded together. The choice of Hagar marked a turning point in the band’s history after the uncertainty following Roth’s departure.

Years later, Van Halen explored other singers when Hagar’s time with the band ended. Mitch Malloy auditioned to replace Sammy Hagar in the summer of 1996, and the band told him he had landed the job. However, when Eddie, Michael Anthony and Alex Van Halen reunited with David Lee Roth at the 1996 MTV Video Music Awards, Malloy knew his opportunity had passed. He formally withdrew from consideration.

Gary Cherone then joined Van Halen in 1996 after a decade fronting the band Extreme. Cherone and the Van Halen members released Van Haler III in 1998, but the album received a lukewarm response from fans and critics, reaching only Gold status compared to the band’s previous platinum releases. Cherone left in 1999 after the band began working on a follow-up album that was never completed.

Share This Article