Primus frontman Les Claypool recently discussed how the band’s new drummer John Hoffman has transformed the group’s dynamic. He shared his thoughts in an interview with Bass Magazine. Hoffman replaced longtime drummer Tim ‘Herb’ Alexander in 2025.
Claypool’s comments came in response to observations about the positive impact Hoffman has brought to the band’s energy and performance.
When asked about how new drummer John Hoffman has brought a spark to the band, Claypool offered insight into the drummer’s personality and playing style. Claypool praised Hoffman’s influence on the band, which might offend former drummer of the band, Tim ‘Herb Alexander.
“He’s kind of a nervous guy, but it’s endearing,” Claypool said. “The first time I heard him talk, he totally reminded me of my younger brother. When they finally met each other, Hoffer was like, ‘Oh man, I see exactly what you’re saying.’ My brother is the type of guy who’s like, ‘Oh, am I in the way? Can I get you anything?’ I tell people that if they ever get a flat tire down in Salinas, I’ll give them my brother’s number, and he’ll come change the flat for you. That’s the way Hoffer is.”
The Primus leader went on to praise Hoffman’s musical abilities and adaptability during performances.
“He’s very imaginative in the way he plays, and he’s just so smooth,” Claypool continued. “And he listens very well. At the award show, me and Marcus Miller were trading back and forth, and Hoffer was right there with it; the three of us were locked in. He’s got big ears, he can think on his feet, he’s a great guy, and he’s just so happy to be there.”
Claypool also noted how Hoffman’s positive attitude has influenced the band’s atmosphere, even during challenging moments.
“Even when he f*cks something up and I turn around to give him the look, he’s got a huge smile, and I just let it go,” he said. “He definitely brings a new energy.”
Hoffman’s arrival marks a significant transition for Primus following the unexpected departure of their longtime drummer Tim Alexander. Alexander had been with the band through multiple iterations of their career.
Live for Live Music reported that Alexander quit Primus abruptly in October 2024. The band said his departure came as a complete shock. Claypool and Larry LaLonde stated it “came as a complete shock to all of us here in the Primus camp.” After attempts to contact him, Alexander replied that he had “lost his passion for playing.”
Alexander later provided additional context about his decision in a Rolling Stone interview. He explained that his comment about losing passion was only part of the story. “All of these tours left me feeling empty. My body hurts constantly,” he said, citing the physical toll of touring as another factor in his departure.
The search for Alexander’s replacement proved to be an extensive process. Metal Injection noted that Primus ran an open audition process that drew over 6,000 drummers before Hoffman was ultimately selected. The scale of the audition process demonstrated both the band’s commitment to finding the right fit and the widespread interest in joining the iconic group.
Ultimate Classic Rock revealed that Hoffman came from the Louisiana band Dirtfoot, described as a “Gypsy Punk Country Grumble Boogie” group. In an interview with Phoenix New Times, Hoffman expressed surprise at the caliber of drummers who participated in the audition process. He mentioned that Nikki Glaspie was leaving as he arrived and Thomas Lang auditioned days later.
Since joining Primus, Hoffman has quickly integrated into the band’s live performances and recording activities. Live for Live Music documented that Primus played its first proper gig after Alexander’s departure with Danny Carey on drums at Tool Live in the Sand in March 2025. The band then introduced Hoffman in his official debut. The band has since announced new 2025 tour dates with Hoffman and released their first new song with him on drums, “Little Lord Fentanyl,” which also featured Maynard James Keenan.
