Steve Vai discussed how David Lee Roth ran the songwriting process during their time together, telling 101 WRIF that the former Van Halen frontman always made the final decisions on which material would be used.
Vai explained that different bandleaders have different styles of working with their musicians. He described how Roth’s approach required the guitarist and other band members to bring finished songs to him for approval.
“Well, people run their ship differently,” Vai said. “Some people need good generals and lieutenants and this kind of thing that they can delegate to. And in the situation with Dave, he needed, especially the guitarist, to bring music to the party.”
“So I, and the other guys too, would write and present the songs, and Dave would decide if he liked it and wanted to work on it or if it was shelved,” he continued. “So, this is how you do it. It’s nice to have an executive decision maker, because there’s no band arguing about whose song is gonna be used or any of that. And many other things, where it’s just like, ‘I don’t know, you gotta ask Dave.’ It lets you off the hook.”
Vai went on to describe Roth’s creative process once he had selected a song. “Also, he was depending on myself and the band to bring music to him,” he said. “He listened to it, if it struck a chord with him, he’d take the cassette, and he’d get in his in Panama – which is that wild, wonderful red car that he has, convertible – and he’d have his driver drive around, and he’d sit in the back, listen and write lyrics to the demo. And then it would become a song.”
Vai’s remarks shed light on how Roth managed the creative process and maintained control over the band’s output during their collaboration.
Vai was a member of Roth’s band from 1985 to 1989, alongside bassist Billy Sheehan, drummer Gregg Bissonette and keyboardist Brett Tuggle. During this time, Vai and Roth worked together on two albums. Roth’s first solo album, Eat ‘Em and Smile, arrived in 1986 and became a commercial success. Vai co-wrote most of the material for that record with Roth, though Sheehan also contributed a track called “Shyboy.”
For the second album, Skyscraper, Vai took on production duties alongside Roth. The two worked on demos together and co-produced the full album in 1988. Unlike the first record, which had been produced by Ted Templeman, Vai and Roth handled the production themselves. According to Vai, they were very detailed in their approach, though they lacked experience as rock producers. Many of the guitar solos on Skyscraper came directly from the demos because Roth was so pleased with them that he decided to keep them.
The band’s lineup shifted with each release, and Vai and Sheehan both left after Skyscraper in 1988. Vai had been working on material for what would become his solo album Passion and Warfare, but he set that project aside when he joined Roth’s band. After parting ways with Roth in 1989, Vai returned to his solo work and completed the album.