Why Maynard James Keenan’s Vocals Are Untouchable In Tool

Widely known for its unique style, Tool has grown their fanbase with its innovative approach to various genres such as progressive rock, art rock, and alternative metal. Their challenging musical textures and introspective lyrics massively contributed to the band to create their original tone. There are probably many other reasons behind their success and becoming such a popular band worldwide with a diverse fanbase.

The internal dynamics in music bands also really matter in this respect. All the band members need to have commitment and passion for surviving in the music industry, which is highly competitive. They also need to compromise on specific issues related to the bands’ musical direction if they want to keep the harmony. Now let’s look at how Tool handles these internal dynamics and their frontman Maynard James Keenan’s role in the band.

How Does Maynard James Keenan Contribute To The Band’s Success?

The composition process in music bands is generally the most stressful period as they feel the pressure to make the best out of themselves. It is mainly driven by the band members’ shared musical tastes and commitment to music-making. Each music band has its specific way of dealing with this process closely related to their internal dynamics.

During an old Music Clinic event, Tool members Adam Jones, Justin Chancellor, and Danny Carey reflected on the band’s general atmosphere and Maynard James Keenan’s role during their creative process. They revealed that every band member’s role within the band is clearly defined, which helps them build their relationship on solid ground and prevent potential divisive disagreements.

Tool members were asked about how the band’s lead singer Maynard James Keenan works and whether he interferes with the songs during the recording sessions. They explained that the singer doesn’t change them at all and handles the vocals in an incredibly perfect way, making his vocals untouchable in the band. They revealed that Keenan would participate in the writing process before, but they decided to clarify everyone’s role within the band and not interfere with each other’s sphere later on.

Tool members speaking on why Keenan’s vocals are untouchable in the group:

“They don’t change at all; Maynard comes in and writes vocals that fit incredibly well without changing anything or asking for any adjustments to the instruments. In the past, Maynard was involved in writing the instruments, but we have learned that it’s best to have each band member have their own clearly defined role.”

It looks like Tool eventually discovered what works best for them during the creative process, probably after experiencing some unpleasant internal conflicts. Thus, they can now work harmoniously to take the group’s success to the next level. Of course, there will be some problems, but at least they seem to be willing to compromise owing to their shared understanding.