Primus bassist Les Claypool recently weighed in on a lighthearted but pointed question about his drumming abilities in an interview on The Doc G Show.
The exchange was prompted by a question from legendary drummer Stewart Copeland. He asked whether Claypool secretly believes he is a better drummer than new Primus drummer John Hoffman. Claypool’s answer was both candid and self-deprecating.
“That’s not what I thought he was gonna ask. But no, not even close. I mean, I can play. But I’m not even close to Hoffer,” Claypool said.
Despite his humble assessment, Claypool noted one small area where he has the edge over Hoffman.
“But I do have one beat that he can’t figure out. I play it for him every now and then,” he continued. “He goes, ‘God dammit.’ He can’t figure it out.”
The comments offer a rare glimpse into the dynamic between Claypool and Hoffman. They also speak to the level of mutual respect that has developed between the two since Hoffman stepped into one of rock’s most demanding drum chairs.
Hoffman joined Primus following the departure of longtime drummer Tim “Herb” Alexander. He has already appeared on new Primus studio material, including “The Ol’ Grizz,” featured on the band’s recently released EP A Handful of Nuggs. The EP also includes a new version of “Holy Diver,” a live track, and a collaboration with Maynard James Keenan. These releases signal that Primus is actively pushing forward with its new lineup rather than simply maintaining the status quo.
The current Primus lineup — Claypool, guitarist Larry “Ler” LaLonde, and Hoffman — is currently on the road for the Claypool Gold Tour. The tour brings together three of Claypool’s projects: Primus, The Claypool Lennon Delirium, and Colonel Les Claypool’s Fearless Flying Frog Brigade. It has drawn strong reactions from fans and critics alike, with Hoffman’s performances consistently drawing praise for their precision and energy.
Hoffman’s arrival has been described as one of the most closely watched drummer transitions in recent rock history. The unique and technically demanding nature of Primus’s catalog made the transition a high-stakes one. Taking on a role previously held by multiple drummers over the band’s 42-year history, Hoffman has been recognized for his ability to honor the band’s sound while bringing his own identity to the kit.
Claypool’s willingness to openly praise Hoffman, even at his own expense, reflects a band in confident transition. Primus is not treating this new chapter as a preservation exercise. New music, a major tour, and a drummer who is clearly earning the respect of his bandmates all point to a group that is still evolving.
