‘It’s an Insult’: Halestorm’s Lzzy Hale Under Fire After Brooks And Dunn Tribute

Jamie Collins
By
Jamie Collins
Jamie serves as our Cultural Historian, focusing on the social impact, career milestones, and cultural significance of the 80s and 90s rock scene. He specializes in...
4 Min Read
Photo Credit: Per Ole Hagen/Getty Images - Vince Bucci/AFP/Getty Images

Lzzy Hale of Halestorm performed a rocked up version of Brooks & Dunn’s “Boot Scootin’ Boogie” at the CMA Awards, drawing mixed reactions from country music fans. The Country Music Association praised the performance on Instagram, but many viewers criticized the band’s approach to the country classic.

Create your own music artist with RockAgent
You follow artists every day. What about creating your own?
RockAgent lets you build a music artist from scratch and take it all the way to release.
Create Your Artist

The performance was a tribute to the country duo, with Halestorm bringing their rock style to the song. However, several country fans felt the arrangement strayed too far from the original.

One country fan commented, “Terrible. Honestly. This hurt my ears. I tried to give it a chance. Wtf. Maybe hit a note properly if not screaming like banshees. Too rocked up. Yuck. Too much twang. Hair. Insult to me as a fan. Poor B & D!”

Another viewer added, “This sounds absolute terrible. And the screaming introduction was absolutely one of the worst I’ve ever heard in any type of award show history. Absolutely repugnant performance.”

A third country fan wrote, “CMA really screwed it up. That’s really sucks, it’s an insult to the Country Singers and Country Music. I like some hard rock, but that really sucks.”

The Country Music Association had a different take, writing in their post, “That CMAawards performance definitely rocked our world!”

Halestorm’s tribute to Brooks & Dunn at the CMA Awards sparked debate over how much rock influence should feature in a country music setting. The performance showed how differently rock and country audiences can view the same stage moment.

This was not Halestorm’s first time performing the song. The Grammy-winning rock band had previously recorded “Boot Scootin’ Boogie” with a hard rock arrangement for Brooks & Dunn’s Reboot II album in 2024. The original “Boot Scootin’ Boogie” was released on Brooks & Dunn’s 1991 debut album Brand New Man and is widely considered the duo’s signature song. Reboot II marks a shift from its predecessor, the 2019 album Reboot, which featured country artists like Luke Combs and Kacey Musgraves. Reboot II instead taps musicians from outside country, including rock bands, bluegrass and blues artists.

Halestorm performed the tribute at the 2026 CMA Awards as Brooks & Dunn were honored with the Willie Nelson Lifetime Achievement Award. The band’s performance featured lead singer Lzzy Hale on vocals, Joe Hottinger on guitar, Josh Smith on bass, and Tommy Clufetos on drums. According to some comments on the CMA’s social media post, Brooks and Dunn had a hand in selecting the tribute artists for the event.

The divide in the comments section reflected broader tensions between country and rock fans over how the classic song should sound. Those defending the performance noted that Ronnie Dunn of Brooks & Dunn had expressed approval of Halestorm’s version. The CMA’s own endorsement of the performance as something that “rocked our world” highlighted how differently the country music establishment and traditional country listeners viewed the tribute.

Share This Article