The Main Difference Between Alice In Chains And Nirvana Is Explained By Chuck Klosterman
Successful author Chuck Klosterman recently reflected on the difference between two pioneering bands of the grunge movement of the early 1990s, Nirvana and Alice In Chains. According to the journalist, the primary distinction between these two groups is the way they responded to fame and the perception of their personality.
Both Alice In Chains and Nirvana were founded in 1987 as two acts of the Seattle grunge scene. These bands fused punk rock and heavy metal elements in songs that included angst-filled and introspective lyrics, often addressing themes such as social alienation, self-doubt, and emotional isolation. When the early grunge movement started to gain attention by the 1990s, its popularity had spread with successful representative bands.
The genre particularly gained commercial success in the early-to-mid-1990s due to famous releases, such as Nirvana’s second studio album entitled ‘Nevermind,’ and Alice In Chains’ second studio record named ‘Dirt.’ In addition to boosting the popularity of their music genre, both of these albums featured grunge anthems such as ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit‘ and ‘Man in the Box.’
Although it’s undeniable that these tracks were both successful, Nirvana’s song has been one of the most well-known, if not the most famous, of grunge music. This is why Chuck Klosterman wrote in his book named ‘Fargo Rock City: A Heavy Metal Odyssey in Rural North Dakota’ that the legacy of ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit’ is not transposable. During a recent conversation with Ultimate Classic Rock, the author was asked if that’s also the case with Alice In Chains’ ‘Man in the Box.’
The journalist started his words by saying that Alice In Chains basically consists of talented musicians who play the music of the time. Even if you consider ‘Man in the Box’ as a huge song, the issue with this band is their common attitude towards their perception. Muck like every other band, Alice In Chains embraces the spot they’re positioned by people, which shows a lack of characteristics.
On the other hand, Nirvana had a unique attitude with their music as they had distinctive lyrics that addressed the modern way of thinking. In addition to their music, the band members, especially frontman Kurt Cobain, had a different behavior towards fame that made them stand out from the others. Their unhappiness with fame, which was present in their music and interviews was more important than the fame itself.
Regarding Alice In Chains, Klosterman said:
“OK, so, Alice In Chains starts out as an ’80s band, and they’re like Guns N’ Roses. They’re ‘Alice N’ Chainz’ with a ‘Z’ at the end, and instead of the word ‘and,’ just the letter ‘N.’ So they are basically a good band with talented musicians who are playing what is the music of the time. So they’re touring with Van Halen, you know, like Soundgarden toured with Guns N’ Roses.
So if ‘Man in the Box’ is the big song, that may have been still slotted into an extension of ’80s metal. And here’s the other part: I think that Alice In Chains would have been like, ‘How are you perceiving us? Well, the way you perceive us is what we are.‘ Because that’s what most bands do. Most bands will kind of, even if they seemingly fight it when asked directly, for the most part, they kind of accept how they are positioned.”
As for Nirvana, the author stated:
“The thing about Nirvana that makes it so specific was that… the chord progression of ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit’ is like Boston’s ‘More Than a Feeling.’ So in that way, it’s a little familiar. And the production of ‘Nevermind,’ as a record, as Kurt Cobain himself said, it’s more like a Mötley Crüe record. The way the drums sound, the cleanness of the sound, just kind of the way it is produced, actually is very much in line with the music of the ’80s. So the song is reminiscent of a huge single from the ’70s. It has the sonic aspects of music that were very popular in the ’80s.
But the look of the band, the attitude of the band, the lyrics that are both kinds of incoherent and yet somehow almost seem to be addressing a modern way of thinking, it was all these things that kind of came together. So when I say it was not transposable, it couldn’t be ‘Black Hole Sun’ or ‘Touch Me I’m Sick.’ I didn’t want to give the sense that this was just going to happen anyway. I don’t think it was just going to happen anyway. I think it had to be this person because Kurt Cobain ended up adopting this adversarial punk ideology that he spoke about incessantly. Their unhappiness with fame was more important than the fame itself. And I am not certain if another group in that position would have behaved in that same way.”
You can listen to ‘Smells Like Teen Spirit’ and ‘Man in the Box’ below.